Thanks, not having much luck with Cineware. Only seeing extracted nulls in AE generated only from nulls out of C4D rather than the individual objects in the clone and with the bend deformer off. That may be ok, as they are on the same plane, but they are doing something entirely different, not matching at all. I see what you did in the C4D version, that works. The Cineware is nice, but have always strayed from it as it can be troublesome. I’m starting to think it will be way easier to just turn the bend off in C4D…
Thxs much for your effort,
Jon